Extate Cranks Up the Heat

The US based realty search engines (Trulia, and to a lesser degree, Redfin) are quickly getting lapped by their European counterparts.

Seems like coming out of the gates, nearly all of the Brits aped Trulia’s ground breaking search interface – but have quickly pushed that aside as they race to add new features (see Extate Launches Video Tours). Now it’s Trulia’s interface that is starting to look at bit dated.

extate, who are competing against the likes of Nestoria, Zoomf (see Zoomf Aims to Help British Home Buyers) and OnOneMap (see OnOneMap Gives You More), faces the cutthroat reality that in a field crowded with competition, they must innovate or die.

That same lack of competition here may mean the reigning kings of the Real Estate 2.0 search game grow complacent (as was the case with Realtor.com before them) – but also means there’s a huge opportunity for new players to come into the game.

A couple of new features extate has developed recently; that US based real estate search engines should perhaps take note of…

  • No more balloon popups. Means the map doesn’t readjust when you select the markers – which I love. Maps jumping all over the place when I’m trying to click on a property. The property information displays the full details in the sidebar which is also nice.
  • Markers change color once you’ve viewed them – a simple yet extremely useful innovation which answers one of the most basic questions a real estate shopper might have; “What freakin’ properties have I already seen here?”

More excitingly, The Heat is On. As I’ve said before, “any data set can be made visually sexier with a heatmap” (Heat Maps Catch on Fire) and Trulia does a nice job of layering heat maps onto city level search as a way to see market activity (e.g. Portland Home Prices and Heat Map).

But extate has taken it one step further and added a fourth tab to the Google map that along with Satellite and Hybrid imagery provide heat maps of local prices per square foot (their implementation recalls the visually stunning GeoIQ mashups). This is a great feature that coupled with more specific local information, could be adopted by many of the big brokers too (see Big Brokers Going Local).

heat.jpg

All of these advances however, mean very little without a clear monetization strategy – which is one area that Trulia (and again, to a lesser degree, Redfin) have focused much more of their energies to date. That said, it’d be nice to see some of this innovation trickle over to this side of the pond one of these days.

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!

Make sure to follow Inman News on Twitter too!


RSS Feed for This Post3 Comment(s)

  1. Richard | Apr 17, 2007 | Reply

    Zoom out one level, then move the map just a little bit. Suddenly the heat map looks different. White spots are no longer white and dark spots moved, too. That doesn’t give me much confidence in the underlying data.

    “they must innovate or die.”
    I’m sorry, is this another web2.0 slogan? I agree that there should be some way of generating revenue (”they must make money or die”). The first-in-the-market strategy (e.g. Ebay or Trulia) can’t work as there is too much competition.

    Richard

  2. Artemi Krymski | Apr 17, 2007 | Reply

    Richard,

    The heat map is calculated relative to the area you are viewing, so when you zoom out a certain area that was hot may now become cold (which makes sense because its in comparison to other areas that were not visible before). We could not let the user move and zoom and make one static heat map (which would be much easier) but in my opinion is restrictive.

    I do agree that there are still lots of improvements to be made to the underlying algorithms that will improve the accuracy a lot, as well as obtaining more price data.

    I also agree that its not all about innovation. In fact there are lots of companies that die because all they do is innovate and don’t watch their bottom line. We strive to do both, but innovation is what we love, and revenue strategies are fairly standard in this market (nobody yet has come up with something revolutionary – as far as I know)

    Thank you for your feedback!

    —————-

    Joel,

    Thanks for the great article and an interesting discussion. IMHO I’m not convinced that UK property sites are that much better, most of them are poor clones of Trulia (which is why they almost got sued). The grass is always greener on the other side :)

  3. shaun mclane | May 1, 2007 | Reply

    Finally had a chance to look check out extate today. Nice site. Not sure I agree with the hype, but I’ve only spent a few minutes looking.

5 Trackback(s)

  1. From The Garden Gossip | Nov 30, 1999
  2. From Real Estate Valuation Going to the Consumer « Better Closer Blog | Apr 17, 2007
  3. From Matt Goyer’s Real Estate Blog » Blog Archive » Joel on Extate | Apr 21, 2007
  4. From Redfin Gets a Facelift and Expands Eastward | Future of Real Estate Marketing Blog | Apr 25, 2007
  5. From Comeover.com - The Blog : Redfin Gets Cool | Apr 26, 2007

RSS Feed for This PostPost a Comment